Researchers Look at Pre-K TB Screening
July 26, 2007
Researchers Look at Pre-K TB Screening
States and school districts differ on whether all children should be
tested for tuberculosis infection before they enter kindergarten, and
an article in the July issue of the journal Pediatrics asks
whether such universal testing is cost-effective. Using California as
an example, researchers noted that public officials have made decisions
about whether to require testing "based on the available evidence and
local preferences." A universal TST (tuberculosis skin test) is
mandated as part of the screening component of the Early and Periodic
Screening Diagnosis and Treatment (EPSDT) program, and the researchers
note that routine skin testing of all children is still practiced in
many parts of the United States. That's despite a recommendation by the
Pediatric Tuberculosis Collaborative Group, which recommended in 2004
that universal TST should be replaced by "risk factor screening" based
on responses to questions such as country of birth, travel history,
exposure to TB, and close contact with someone with positive TST
results. When they looked at the cost-effectiveness of universal versus
targeted screening (in terms of the costs of full-blown tuberculosis to
the health system), the researchers concluded that they "strongly
support" the recommendations of the Pediatric Tuberculosis Group for
discontinuing universal TST of children. The article,
"Cost-effectiveness of Alternative Strategies for Tuberculosis
Screening Before Kindergarten Entry" appears in the July 2007 issue of
the journal Pediatrics.